"The market in early November is clearly weaker than it was a month ago, and the weakness now shows in almost every measure." That was the Cromford Report's summary for Greater Phoenix at the start of this month. It added that the contract ratio had fallen to its lowest level since February 2009.
Scottsdale has followed its own pattern this fall. In the 30 days to September 29, Cromford's Market Index fell in 17 of the 18 major Valley cities it tracks. Scottsdale was the only one to rise, from 154.4 to 155.3. So a Scottsdale owner thinking about selling this winter isn't asking the same question as an owner in the broader metro. The question is narrower. When does a Scottsdale listing face the fewest competing homes?
Last winter's monthly numbers give a clear answer. A Scottsdale home listed in January faced nearly twice as many new listings as one listed in December, while the share of list price that buyers paid barely changed.
Where Scottsdale stands going into December
Scottsdale REALTORS publishes a monthly market report covering single-family homes, condos and townhomes. The October 2026 report shows 454 sales during the month, a median sold price of $964,500, 5.45 months of inventory and a sold-to-list ratio of 96.8%. At the end of October there were 2,711 active listings, and 963 new listings had come on during the month.
The same report from a year earlier shows the trend. In October 2025, Scottsdale recorded 529 sales at a median of $885,000, with 5.1 months of inventory. Comparing the two Octobers, sales fell about 14% while the median sold price rose about 9%. Scottsdale is closing fewer deals at higher prices.
The wider Valley has more slack. ARMLS's November STAT report, which covers October data, puts metro months of supply at 6.04, up from 4.72 a year earlier. It also shows sales under $500,000 down 14.5% year over year, while sales above $2 million made up a slightly larger share than in previous months. Scottsdale's 5.45 months of inventory is tighter than the metro's 6.04. The Valley's softness is concentrated in the price ranges where Scottsdale has the fewest homes.
Borrowing costs are higher than they were last winter. Freddie Mac's 30-year fixed average was 7.11% for the week of November 12, 2026, compared with 6.24% a year earlier. That puts more weight on the buyers who are ready now. It also makes it more expensive to spend weeks competing with other listings.
Last December, the field thinned out
For a seller, the most useful month in last winter's data is December 2025.
| Month | New listings | Active listings | Sold | Median sold price | Months of inventory | Median days |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Oct 2025 | 983 | 2,660 | 529 | $885,000 | 5.1 | 46 |
| Nov 2025 | 740 | 2,616 | 437 | $910,000 | 4.99 | 43 |
| Dec 2025 | 642 | 2,490 | 588 | $999,500 | 4.7 | 42 |
| Jan 2026 | 1,212 | 2,948 | 470 | $976,900 | 5.61 | 57 |
| Feb 2026 | 951 | 3,049 | 554 | $990,000 | 5.76 | 42 |
| Mar 2026 | 1,043 | 3,158 | 685 | $994,800 | 6.11 | 44 |
All figures are from the Scottsdale REALTORS monthly reports for each month, single-family plus condo and townhome.
In December 2025, only 642 homes came on the market in Scottsdale, the fewest of the season. Buyers closed on 588 homes that month, more than in any month from October through February. Months of inventory dropped to 4.7, the lowest reading in the table. The median sold price reached $999,500, also the highest in the table, and median days on market was 42.
Of the six months in the table, December had the smallest gap between homes coming on the market and homes closing: 642 new listings against 588 sales.
January brought more sellers as well as buyers
Winter in Scottsdale is usually described in terms of the buyers who arrive, such as seasonal residents and out-of-town shoppers. Last winter's data shows the sellers arriving too, and in larger numbers.
In January 2026, 1,212 new listings came on in Scottsdale, nearly double December's 642. Active listings grew by about 460 homes to 2,948, and months of inventory rose to 5.61. Sales dropped to 470 and median days on market jumped to 57, the longest in the six months shown.
Inventory kept building after that. Active listings rose to 3,049 in February and to 3,158 in March, and months of inventory climbed to 5.76 and then 6.11. Sales picked up as well, to 685 in March, but they did not keep pace with the supply. A home listed in mid-January was competing with roughly 450 more homes than a December listing, and that number kept growing for two months.
Last winter, waiting showed up in days on market
Scottsdale's sold-to-list ratio stayed between 96.5% and 97% every month from October 2025 through March 2026. Buyers paid about the same share of the final list price in the thin December market as in the crowded March market. The median sold price stayed within a narrow band between $976,900 and $999,500 from December through March.
Two things moved more: how long a home sat and how many alternatives each buyer had. Median days on market went from 42 in December to 57 in January. A January seller was paying carrying costs for more weeks while buyers compared the home with nearly twice as many new listings.
That's why the gap between asking prices and sold prices matters this year. In the October 2026 report, the median list price of new listings was $1,100,000 and the median for active listings was $995,000, compared with a median sold price of $964,500. Some of that gap reflects the mix of homes that list in a given month. Still, it shows new sellers starting above where deals have been closing. In a thin market, a buyer has fewer homes to compare an overpriced listing against. In January's market, the same listing is easy to pass over. A seller who lists in December at a price close to recent sales gets the advantage of the smaller field. A seller who waits for January and also prices high is likely to sit through the long-days stretch.
The top of the market is still active
Scottsdale's high end kept trading through the fall. The Arizona Republic reported that a north Scottsdale mansion where Kobe Bryant once played sold for $14 million, among the Valley's most expensive sales in the first week of October. The Republic also reported Paradise Valley sales of $13.1 million and $9.75 million this fall. Together with ARMLS's finding that sales over $2 million made up a slightly larger share of October activity, these sales point to the same thing. The metro slowdown has hit hardest below $500,000, while Scottsdale's buyers have kept closing.
Scottsdale isn't one uniform market, and the seasonal pattern plays out differently from Old Town to the northern golf communities. Our earlier post on what a budget buys across Scottsdale's submarkets covers how each area works. The citywide calendar is the starting point, and the street-level comparables decide the actual list price.
A few practical questions
Will a home listed over the holidays just sit? Last December it didn't. Median days on market was 42 in December 2025, tied with February for the shortest in that six-month window. The long waits came in January, at a median of 57 days.
What if the home won't be ready until January? Then the preparation has to account for the crowd it will join. In January 2026, a new listing went up against about 1,200 other new listings that month, and buyers had nearly six months of supply to pick from. Staging, photography and pricing set against recent sales matter more in that month than in any other.
Does this year's weaker metro market change the December case? It makes the timing count for more. With the metro at 6.04 months of supply and mortgage rates above 7%, each active buyer has more homes to choose from across the Valley. A December listing reaches the buyers shopping in late fall before the January wave of new listings arrives.
If you're weighing whether to get your home on the market before the holidays or hold it for the new year, The Nelson Group can put your street's recent sales next to last winter's calendar and help you decide which month suits your home. You can start with a home valuation or meet our sellers team to plan the prep around the date you choose.